Skip to main content
Sabrang
Sabrang
Politics India

Morbi reflects the ‘revadi culture’ of the Gujarat Model

Vidya Bhushan Rawat 04 Nov 2022

Morbi

The bridge collapse at Morbi in Gujarat killed over 140 people and many missing but no head has been rolled. According to reports there were 33 children aged between one to ten years. The 143 years old and 230 meters long suspension bridge was made during the British period. It was also claimed that the bridge was in an extremely bad conditions and a private contractor was asked to renovate it. The company was asked to complete it by December 2022 but the inauguration was advanced and we all know ‘why’. Elections in Himachal Pradesh have been declared. There is a gap between the voting and the results in that tiny state where results could easily be declared on the very next day but the Election Commission deliberately kept it like that because it will finally declare the dates for Gujarat polls but that would not happen unless all the programmes that both the prime minister and union home minister Amit Shah had been completed. Now the Election Commission has finally declared dates for Gujarat elections, citing delay in the declaration because of the Morbi tragedy.

Now coming back to Morbi,  and the tragedy that unfolded on the evening of October 30, we are informed that about seven persons have been arrested who include the clerk and other workers of the company. Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who was busy both campaigning and inaugurating various schemes in Gujarat also felt ‘pained’ to hear the deaths of innocent at the Morbi Bridge collapse. He did not, however, bother to cancel his programmes. The lavishness with which these programmes were organised show the highest level of insensitivity at the time when the nation was mourning this tragic loss of life. The prime minister was however participating in various event to promote his party and his personality.  

While Modi was busy ‘electioneering’ in Gujarat, it was the Manu-stream media that started building up another narrative. The shameless and thuggish ‘experts’ wanted people ‘not to politicise’ the issue. They did not have the courage to demand that the prime minister stop his political campaigns using public funds (in Gujarat) but they continued to ask questions to people. A well-known anchor on ‘prime time’ actually blamed the people themselves for the collapse of the bridge. This is the man who dishes out ample ‘wisdom’ to people on his prime-time programmes with a one-point agenda: to defame opponents of the prime minister and defend his most indefensible actions.

Look at who was given the contract to repair the suspension bridge by the Morbi Municipality. You should not be surprised because that is the modus operandi being followed diligently for the last so many years under Narendra Modi. It is the same method which make Anil Ambani’s company ‘expert’ in defence manufacturing as happened in the case when Rafael deal was done. At Morbi town, the Oreva company, which makes watches and bikes was given the ‘revadi’ for repairing and maintaining the bridge. What does the company do? It paints the cables of the old structure, put some artificial aluminium plates and is compelled to advance the inauguration. Why?

The bridge was being maintained by Oreva company since 2008. Its owner Jayasukh Bhai Patel reportedly told media that the company invested Rs 20 million in repairing and maintenance of the bridge and nothing would happen to the bride for next fifteen twenty years, as reported by the BBC. After the tragic manmade disaster, however, the police arrested two managers, two ticket clerks, three guards and two more people but nothing happened to Oreva group owner and the Morbi municipality leaders. The fact that the lawyers in Morbi decided not to fight the cases of these low-level employees making them responsible and guilty before any court could pronounce them so, shows the complete hypocrisy on their part.

Now the government claims that only Rs 28 lakh was spent (not Rs 2 crores) as the cable which was supposed to be changed was never done. The question is what action will the government take against the owner of the company and the corporation who seem hand in glove with each other? Unfortunately, rather than questioning those responsible for not carrying out maintenance accordingly and those who gave it a fitness certificate, the lawyers of Morbi, too, feel that the poor people are responsible for the same. It is very much like the Manu-stream TV anchors who say that it is the people who were responsible for the accident.

For readers here, Jaysukh Bhai Patel is reported to have authored a book ‘Samasya aur samadhan’ i.e. The problem and the solution, 2019 when he writes and analyses as to what stops India from becoming Vishwaguru? He says, ‘stop the elections and hand over the country to some ‘able’ man for next 15-20 years like China who works like Hitler’. He is anti-reservation and feel that only dictators can give us freedom from corruption. He is upset about land acquisition and opines that the government must act like China as it is the owner of all the land in India and farmers and zamindars are just leaseholders.’ 

Now, one can understand just what kind of people have been promoted by the BJP’s crony-ism and why action has not been taken against this criminal who violated all the laws to open the bridge when it was not ready.

Why are the people of Gujarat,  political parties –including those in Opposition – quiet quiet on Jaysukh Patel? Why has he not been arrested?

Narendra Modi visited the Morbi hospital the next day. The hospital was made ‘lively’ for the prime minister so that he does not experience any hardship when inside the hospital. It was painted. The rescue operations were stopped to ensure that they work when Narendra Modi was there. It was converted into an event. Since Narendra Modi has finished giving ‘revadis’ to Gujarat, the Election Commission has now declared the dates for Gujarat polls today. 

How is it that Narendra Modi and his party continue to disregard common concern and public opinion in Gujarat? Is it because the Savarna (read upper caste) culture in Gujarat has become so dominant that despite absolute an failure of governance during the Covid crisis, joblessness, health crisis and despicable educational system, Modi’s Gujarat model is ‘famous’ and the Gujaratis world over feel so overwhelmed with his model.

Is this decay of Gujarati society responsible for the fact that political parties refuse to stand with Zakia Jaffari who is genuinely fighting to get justice? Why is it that Gujarat needs a Muslim villain to protect its ‘identity? The Aam Admi Party which, in Punjab and Delhi, claimed to be following the path of Shaheed Bhagat Singh and Dr Baba Saheb Ambedkar is functioning in opposition to the ideologies of the two legends.

While the BJP’s central leadership cannot deny its justification for the release of the rapists of Bilkis Bano and killers her children and family members, Arvind Kejriwal and AAP’s deafening silence on the issue exposed the nature of Gujarat politics and the opportunism of many political parties. 

All these convicts were released for ‘good conduct’ in the jail. These are the same parties and people which exploited the ‘Nirbhaya’ rape case in 2013 in Delhi. Ar that time the common refrain among the ‘activist’ was to hang the culprits and so the case was fast-tracked and culprits were hanged to death. The same parties and leaders refused to take a stand on criminals and thugs who have –on August 15, 2022, India’s 75th Independence Day--been released by the Central and Gujarat government. This is India’s biggest shame that a man who claim to speak on behalf of 130 crore Indians refuses to take a stand on the issue of the peremptory release of rapists and murderers by the government he heads, the central government.

There is no protest in Gujarat against the release. There are no protests and no outrage around the Morbi’s killings. All efforts will be made during elections to again create the favourable pitch of bringing in a ‘Muslim villain’. The positive stories, the sacrifices and the work by the Muslim community is given either a miss or is completely ignored. Three men, Taufik Bhai, Naeem Sheikh, Hussain Pathan saved more than 85 people including children. They have been hailed as heroes by all Indians but the Gujarat government would not do anything to give them a heroic salutation. Let us see how long will this story remain in the media. They would Come election time and amnesia will grip media too.

For years, Narendra Modi and BJP never bothered about political niceties and was also responsible for crude politicisation. In April 2016, when an overbridge collapsed in Kolkata, Modi’s words reflected a cynical language, unbefitting of a prime minister. As reported by India Today, he said, "It is an act of god in the sense that it happened during election time so that people may know what kind of government she has been running. God has sent a message to the people - that today this bridge has collapsed, tomorrow she will finish off entire Bengal. God's message to you all is to save Bengal.”

Right from Uttarakhand’s devastating Kedarnath tragedy in 2013 or the 2016 Nirbhaya gang rape, both the BJP and RSS have used all opportunities politically. They gave no credit to the government of the day if the response was quick or good. They brazenly shifted the narrative to say that it not other elected governments but the Indian forces who did the work! For all  subsequent “successes” of the Indian army under their own regime, it was the achievement of only one man, the prime minister.

The Union government is writing a new script every day with the active support from manu-stream media and the bureaucracy. It is re-defining Indian nationalism, vilifying Muslims. The biggest achievement of Narendra Modi government is ‘nationalisation’ and ‘normalisation’ of hatred against Muslims and absolute freedom to ‘institutions’ which are supposed to protect our rights to behave like the organs of the Bharatiya Janata Party.

Media and politicians both are speaking the language of their cronies who are funding them and it is reflected very much in the crisis that has happened in Delhi which is the most polluted city of India. All standards of clean air (minus pollution) have gone haywire in Delhi. It is a regular feature after Diwali but the media and the government put the blame on the stubble burning by Punjab farmers. Kejriwal used to accuse the Punjab government in the earlier times but right now he is doing nothing. His ministers blame farmers but shamelessly don’t tell people that fire crackers, unmindful construction work and vehicular traffic are the real cause. In the last few years corporate sponsored politicians as well as media have kept the blame of the Delhi’s pollution on farmers alone so that the criminal cronies are saved and continue to fund these parties.

Right from Gujarat to Delhi, the message from those in power is clear that they will protect their cronies and build new, twisted narrative to blame the people, the poor for the fault of those in power. They will not express any regret or apology for any mistakes or misdeeds but continue to play politics with people’s lives.

As citizens of India, we can only express our sorrow at things happening. The question however is how long will the people in power protect the cronies? How long will the manu-stream media continue to play the role of the biggest villain of our democracy? We must share our own blame for not supporting the right people and those who are trying to bring facts and analysis to us. The time is ripe for people to support all the alternative forms of media which stand for people and their rights. If we do not support such initiatives, we will ourselves have to blame for the crisis after Morbi, nothing would happen to the party as it will continue to win ‘trust’ of people in Gujarat.

The country needs to be saved from such cynicism but that is only possible if intellectuals too come out of their safety zones and speak up and support independent alternative media which can expose the attempt by the cronies to create the narrative of the alternative against the BJP by promoting Arvind Kejriwal who has clearly shown where does he stand and what are his priorities. 

If. we don’t wake up sooner than later we will realise all liberals, seculars media will be jumping on this conclusion as the corporate want everything in its hand. It would not allow India go back to those who commit to secularism-social justice and welfare state. 

The Gujarat model is nothing but the same where our national assets are handed over to private cronies and in return they charge money from people without providing them any safety. The crime of Overa company therefore, at Morbi is much bigger because it charged money from the people but did not provide any safety. Uttarakhand states have numerous such Jhoolapuls, suspension bridges and hopefully, the Gujarat model does not come there where they charge every one who uses these to reach his village.

For the people of Uttarakhand, these bridges are not ‘history tourism’ but the need for connecting one village to other. Morbi has the rot been called or showcased as the Gujarat model. Will the people of Gujarat ever accept it ?

Disclaimer: The views expressed here are the author's personal views, and do not necessarily represent the views of Sabrangindia.

Morbi reflects the ‘revadi culture’ of the Gujarat Model

Morbi

The bridge collapse at Morbi in Gujarat killed over 140 people and many missing but no head has been rolled. According to reports there were 33 children aged between one to ten years. The 143 years old and 230 meters long suspension bridge was made during the British period. It was also claimed that the bridge was in an extremely bad conditions and a private contractor was asked to renovate it. The company was asked to complete it by December 2022 but the inauguration was advanced and we all know ‘why’. Elections in Himachal Pradesh have been declared. There is a gap between the voting and the results in that tiny state where results could easily be declared on the very next day but the Election Commission deliberately kept it like that because it will finally declare the dates for Gujarat polls but that would not happen unless all the programmes that both the prime minister and union home minister Amit Shah had been completed. Now the Election Commission has finally declared dates for Gujarat elections, citing delay in the declaration because of the Morbi tragedy.

Now coming back to Morbi,  and the tragedy that unfolded on the evening of October 30, we are informed that about seven persons have been arrested who include the clerk and other workers of the company. Prime Minister Narendra Modi, who was busy both campaigning and inaugurating various schemes in Gujarat also felt ‘pained’ to hear the deaths of innocent at the Morbi Bridge collapse. He did not, however, bother to cancel his programmes. The lavishness with which these programmes were organised show the highest level of insensitivity at the time when the nation was mourning this tragic loss of life. The prime minister was however participating in various event to promote his party and his personality.  

While Modi was busy ‘electioneering’ in Gujarat, it was the Manu-stream media that started building up another narrative. The shameless and thuggish ‘experts’ wanted people ‘not to politicise’ the issue. They did not have the courage to demand that the prime minister stop his political campaigns using public funds (in Gujarat) but they continued to ask questions to people. A well-known anchor on ‘prime time’ actually blamed the people themselves for the collapse of the bridge. This is the man who dishes out ample ‘wisdom’ to people on his prime-time programmes with a one-point agenda: to defame opponents of the prime minister and defend his most indefensible actions.

Look at who was given the contract to repair the suspension bridge by the Morbi Municipality. You should not be surprised because that is the modus operandi being followed diligently for the last so many years under Narendra Modi. It is the same method which make Anil Ambani’s company ‘expert’ in defence manufacturing as happened in the case when Rafael deal was done. At Morbi town, the Oreva company, which makes watches and bikes was given the ‘revadi’ for repairing and maintaining the bridge. What does the company do? It paints the cables of the old structure, put some artificial aluminium plates and is compelled to advance the inauguration. Why?

The bridge was being maintained by Oreva company since 2008. Its owner Jayasukh Bhai Patel reportedly told media that the company invested Rs 20 million in repairing and maintenance of the bridge and nothing would happen to the bride for next fifteen twenty years, as reported by the BBC. After the tragic manmade disaster, however, the police arrested two managers, two ticket clerks, three guards and two more people but nothing happened to Oreva group owner and the Morbi municipality leaders. The fact that the lawyers in Morbi decided not to fight the cases of these low-level employees making them responsible and guilty before any court could pronounce them so, shows the complete hypocrisy on their part.

Now the government claims that only Rs 28 lakh was spent (not Rs 2 crores) as the cable which was supposed to be changed was never done. The question is what action will the government take against the owner of the company and the corporation who seem hand in glove with each other? Unfortunately, rather than questioning those responsible for not carrying out maintenance accordingly and those who gave it a fitness certificate, the lawyers of Morbi, too, feel that the poor people are responsible for the same. It is very much like the Manu-stream TV anchors who say that it is the people who were responsible for the accident.

For readers here, Jaysukh Bhai Patel is reported to have authored a book ‘Samasya aur samadhan’ i.e. The problem and the solution, 2019 when he writes and analyses as to what stops India from becoming Vishwaguru? He says, ‘stop the elections and hand over the country to some ‘able’ man for next 15-20 years like China who works like Hitler’. He is anti-reservation and feel that only dictators can give us freedom from corruption. He is upset about land acquisition and opines that the government must act like China as it is the owner of all the land in India and farmers and zamindars are just leaseholders.’ 

Now, one can understand just what kind of people have been promoted by the BJP’s crony-ism and why action has not been taken against this criminal who violated all the laws to open the bridge when it was not ready.

Why are the people of Gujarat,  political parties –including those in Opposition – quiet quiet on Jaysukh Patel? Why has he not been arrested?

Narendra Modi visited the Morbi hospital the next day. The hospital was made ‘lively’ for the prime minister so that he does not experience any hardship when inside the hospital. It was painted. The rescue operations were stopped to ensure that they work when Narendra Modi was there. It was converted into an event. Since Narendra Modi has finished giving ‘revadis’ to Gujarat, the Election Commission has now declared the dates for Gujarat polls today. 

How is it that Narendra Modi and his party continue to disregard common concern and public opinion in Gujarat? Is it because the Savarna (read upper caste) culture in Gujarat has become so dominant that despite absolute an failure of governance during the Covid crisis, joblessness, health crisis and despicable educational system, Modi’s Gujarat model is ‘famous’ and the Gujaratis world over feel so overwhelmed with his model.

Is this decay of Gujarati society responsible for the fact that political parties refuse to stand with Zakia Jaffari who is genuinely fighting to get justice? Why is it that Gujarat needs a Muslim villain to protect its ‘identity? The Aam Admi Party which, in Punjab and Delhi, claimed to be following the path of Shaheed Bhagat Singh and Dr Baba Saheb Ambedkar is functioning in opposition to the ideologies of the two legends.

While the BJP’s central leadership cannot deny its justification for the release of the rapists of Bilkis Bano and killers her children and family members, Arvind Kejriwal and AAP’s deafening silence on the issue exposed the nature of Gujarat politics and the opportunism of many political parties. 

All these convicts were released for ‘good conduct’ in the jail. These are the same parties and people which exploited the ‘Nirbhaya’ rape case in 2013 in Delhi. Ar that time the common refrain among the ‘activist’ was to hang the culprits and so the case was fast-tracked and culprits were hanged to death. The same parties and leaders refused to take a stand on criminals and thugs who have –on August 15, 2022, India’s 75th Independence Day--been released by the Central and Gujarat government. This is India’s biggest shame that a man who claim to speak on behalf of 130 crore Indians refuses to take a stand on the issue of the peremptory release of rapists and murderers by the government he heads, the central government.

There is no protest in Gujarat against the release. There are no protests and no outrage around the Morbi’s killings. All efforts will be made during elections to again create the favourable pitch of bringing in a ‘Muslim villain’. The positive stories, the sacrifices and the work by the Muslim community is given either a miss or is completely ignored. Three men, Taufik Bhai, Naeem Sheikh, Hussain Pathan saved more than 85 people including children. They have been hailed as heroes by all Indians but the Gujarat government would not do anything to give them a heroic salutation. Let us see how long will this story remain in the media. They would Come election time and amnesia will grip media too.

For years, Narendra Modi and BJP never bothered about political niceties and was also responsible for crude politicisation. In April 2016, when an overbridge collapsed in Kolkata, Modi’s words reflected a cynical language, unbefitting of a prime minister. As reported by India Today, he said, "It is an act of god in the sense that it happened during election time so that people may know what kind of government she has been running. God has sent a message to the people - that today this bridge has collapsed, tomorrow she will finish off entire Bengal. God's message to you all is to save Bengal.”

Right from Uttarakhand’s devastating Kedarnath tragedy in 2013 or the 2016 Nirbhaya gang rape, both the BJP and RSS have used all opportunities politically. They gave no credit to the government of the day if the response was quick or good. They brazenly shifted the narrative to say that it not other elected governments but the Indian forces who did the work! For all  subsequent “successes” of the Indian army under their own regime, it was the achievement of only one man, the prime minister.

The Union government is writing a new script every day with the active support from manu-stream media and the bureaucracy. It is re-defining Indian nationalism, vilifying Muslims. The biggest achievement of Narendra Modi government is ‘nationalisation’ and ‘normalisation’ of hatred against Muslims and absolute freedom to ‘institutions’ which are supposed to protect our rights to behave like the organs of the Bharatiya Janata Party.

Media and politicians both are speaking the language of their cronies who are funding them and it is reflected very much in the crisis that has happened in Delhi which is the most polluted city of India. All standards of clean air (minus pollution) have gone haywire in Delhi. It is a regular feature after Diwali but the media and the government put the blame on the stubble burning by Punjab farmers. Kejriwal used to accuse the Punjab government in the earlier times but right now he is doing nothing. His ministers blame farmers but shamelessly don’t tell people that fire crackers, unmindful construction work and vehicular traffic are the real cause. In the last few years corporate sponsored politicians as well as media have kept the blame of the Delhi’s pollution on farmers alone so that the criminal cronies are saved and continue to fund these parties.

Right from Gujarat to Delhi, the message from those in power is clear that they will protect their cronies and build new, twisted narrative to blame the people, the poor for the fault of those in power. They will not express any regret or apology for any mistakes or misdeeds but continue to play politics with people’s lives.

As citizens of India, we can only express our sorrow at things happening. The question however is how long will the people in power protect the cronies? How long will the manu-stream media continue to play the role of the biggest villain of our democracy? We must share our own blame for not supporting the right people and those who are trying to bring facts and analysis to us. The time is ripe for people to support all the alternative forms of media which stand for people and their rights. If we do not support such initiatives, we will ourselves have to blame for the crisis after Morbi, nothing would happen to the party as it will continue to win ‘trust’ of people in Gujarat.

The country needs to be saved from such cynicism but that is only possible if intellectuals too come out of their safety zones and speak up and support independent alternative media which can expose the attempt by the cronies to create the narrative of the alternative against the BJP by promoting Arvind Kejriwal who has clearly shown where does he stand and what are his priorities. 

If. we don’t wake up sooner than later we will realise all liberals, seculars media will be jumping on this conclusion as the corporate want everything in its hand. It would not allow India go back to those who commit to secularism-social justice and welfare state. 

The Gujarat model is nothing but the same where our national assets are handed over to private cronies and in return they charge money from people without providing them any safety. The crime of Overa company therefore, at Morbi is much bigger because it charged money from the people but did not provide any safety. Uttarakhand states have numerous such Jhoolapuls, suspension bridges and hopefully, the Gujarat model does not come there where they charge every one who uses these to reach his village.

For the people of Uttarakhand, these bridges are not ‘history tourism’ but the need for connecting one village to other. Morbi has the rot been called or showcased as the Gujarat model. Will the people of Gujarat ever accept it ?

Disclaimer: The views expressed here are the author's personal views, and do not necessarily represent the views of Sabrangindia.

Related Articles

Sunday

03

Jan

Pan-India

Saturday

05

Dec

05 pm onwards

Rise in Rage!

North Gate, JNU campus

Thursday

26

Nov

10 am onwards

Delhi Chalo

Pan India

Theme

Stop Hate

Hate and Harmony in 2021

A recap of all that transpired across India in terms of hate speech and even outright hate crimes, as well as the persecution of those who dared to speak up against hate. This disturbing harvest of hate should now push us to do more to forge harmony.
Taliban 2021

Taliban in Afghanistan: A look back

Communalism Combat had taken a deep dive into the lives of people of Afghanistan under the Taliban regime. Here we reproduce some of our archives documenting the plight of hapless Afghanis, especially women, who suffered the most under the hardline regime.
2020

Milestones 2020

In the year devastated by the Covid 19 Pandemic, India witnessed apathy against some of its most marginalised people and vilification of dissenters by powerful state and non state actors. As 2020 draws to a close, and hundreds of thousands of Indian farmers continue their protest in the bitter North Indian cold. Read how Indians resisted all attempts to snatch away fundamental and constitutional freedoms.
Migrant Diaries

Migrant Diaries

The 2020 COVID pandemic brought to fore the dismal lives that our migrant workers lead. Read these heartbreaking stories of how they lived before the pandemic, how the lockdown changed their lives and what they’re doing now.

Campaigns

Sunday

03

Jan

Pan-India

Saturday

05

Dec

05 pm onwards

Rise in Rage!

North Gate, JNU campus

Thursday

26

Nov

10 am onwards

Delhi Chalo

Pan India

Videos

Communalism

Bastar violence: Anti-Christian Campaign causes breach in Adivasi unity

Hundreds of Adivasi church-goers across villages in Narayanpur and Bastar, Chhattisgarh have been experiencing boycott, intimidation and violence since December last year, forcing them to leave their homes and live in refugee camps. Reportedly, Adivasi districts across Madhya Pradesh and Chattisgarh is seeing a rise Hindutva mobilisation against Christians .

Communalism

Bastar violence: Anti-Christian Campaign causes breach in Adivasi unity

Hundreds of Adivasi church-goers across villages in Narayanpur and Bastar, Chhattisgarh have been experiencing boycott, intimidation and violence since December last year, forcing them to leave their homes and live in refugee camps. Reportedly, Adivasi districts across Madhya Pradesh and Chattisgarh is seeing a rise Hindutva mobilisation against Christians .

IN FACT

Analysis

Stop Hate

Hate and Harmony in 2021

A recap of all that transpired across India in terms of hate speech and even outright hate crimes, as well as the persecution of those who dared to speak up against hate. This disturbing harvest of hate should now push us to do more to forge harmony.
Taliban 2021

Taliban in Afghanistan: A look back

Communalism Combat had taken a deep dive into the lives of people of Afghanistan under the Taliban regime. Here we reproduce some of our archives documenting the plight of hapless Afghanis, especially women, who suffered the most under the hardline regime.
2020

Milestones 2020

In the year devastated by the Covid 19 Pandemic, India witnessed apathy against some of its most marginalised people and vilification of dissenters by powerful state and non state actors. As 2020 draws to a close, and hundreds of thousands of Indian farmers continue their protest in the bitter North Indian cold. Read how Indians resisted all attempts to snatch away fundamental and constitutional freedoms.
Migrant Diaries

Migrant Diaries

The 2020 COVID pandemic brought to fore the dismal lives that our migrant workers lead. Read these heartbreaking stories of how they lived before the pandemic, how the lockdown changed their lives and what they’re doing now.

Archives