Skip to main content
Sabrang
Sabrang
Freedom Rule of Law

Kerala HC permits screening of Anand Patwardhan’s documentary on religious fundamentalism, “Reason/Vivek”

Sabrangindia 25 Jun 2019

In what could be a major relief for the renowned Indian documentary filmmaker Anand Patwardhan and the upholding of the freedom of speech and expression by an independent Judiciary, the Kerala High Court (HC) today permitted the screening of Patwardhan’s documentary ‘Reason/Vivek’ in the ongoing International Documentary and Short Film Festival at Thiruvananthapuram on the grounds that “apprehension that the documentary might affect law and order was not a valid reason to withhold sanction.” 


2-Poster-Reason-bike-orange-crop
Image Courtesy:patwardhan.com

The two writ petitioners, Kerala State Chalachitra Academy, the organizer of the festival and the filmmaker Patwardhan, approached the HC after the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting (I&B) rejected its application seeking permission for the screening of the documentary on the grounds that “the theme of the documentary was sensitive in nature and may have law and order ramifications.”

The four-hour documentary is based on the rise of religious fundamentalism in India in the backdrop of murder of rationalists such as Narendra Dabholkar, Govind Pansare, M.M.Kalburgi, Gauri Lankesh among others. The film begins by looking into the murders these rationalists and the role of the Sanatan Sanstha in spreading right-wing extremist violence. It then goes on to Dalit protests and the rise of Dalit leaders in recent years, and ends in Dadri, Mohammad Akhlaq’s village. The film has won a number of awards across the world, including the award for the Best Feature-Length Documentary at the 31st International Documentary Film Festival, Amsterdam.

According to section 9 of the Cinematograph Act, 1952, the films which are not certified by the Central Board of Film Certification requires special exemption from the Central government for public exhibition. Thus, the organizing academy had on May 27 submitted an application to the I&B Ministry seeking exemption for 161 documentaries, that were to be screened in the festival. Notably, on June 17 the Ministry sent back a list of documentaries which received exemption but Patwardhan’s film was absent from that list. After repeated attempts of finding out the reason for rejection, the Ministry finally responded yesterday stating that the film’s subject is sensitive which may cause law and order problems.

Consequently, the petitioners filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution in the HC today stating that the “mere apprehension of law and order breakdown is not a valid ground to suppress free speech.” The matter was heard by a single judge bench comprising of Justice Shaji P. Chaly.

The petitioners, represented by Advocate Sudhi Vasudevan and Jose Jones Joseph, cited the 2017 judgement of the Kerala HC which had quashed the Centre’s denial of sanction to screen the documentaries ‘March, March, March’ and ‘The Unbearable Lightness of Being’ in the same festival on the grounds that “freedom of speech and expression guaranteed by the Constitution includes the right to express one’s political views as well. Film is a legitimate and effective medium..” The two films were based on protests in JNU and suicide of Rohit Vemula respectively. 

Granting the screening permission, Justice Chaly stated that the “apprehension that the documentary might affect law and order was not a valid reason to withhold sanction. Even as per the guidelines framed by the I&B Ministry in this regard, the screening of the documentary is permissible.” However, the Judge clearly stated that the documentary should not be screened elsewhere except in the festival. 

Festival director Kamal told the New Indian Express that since the film is already available on YouTube and has been viewed many times, it does not make sense for the Centre to deny permission straight off the bat.

Anand Patwardhan is known for his socio-political, human rights-oriented films and has been a winner of several national and international awards. His films have sparked multiple controversies in the past as well, due to their strong and sometimes unpalatable messages (for the government). His films like ‘Ram ke Naam’ (on Babri Masjid demolition), ‘Father, Sun and Holy War’ (on post Babri riots), ‘A Narmada Diary’ etc led to protests from radical elements. 

The documentary and short film festival is being held from June 21 to June 26.

Related Articles:
  1. The New ‘Emergency’!
  2. A Biased Media can Weaken Democracy: Justice K.M. Joseph
  3. Today the basic question is not just of freedom of speech, but also freedom after speech

Kerala HC permits screening of Anand Patwardhan’s documentary on religious fundamentalism, “Reason/Vivek”

In what could be a major relief for the renowned Indian documentary filmmaker Anand Patwardhan and the upholding of the freedom of speech and expression by an independent Judiciary, the Kerala High Court (HC) today permitted the screening of Patwardhan’s documentary ‘Reason/Vivek’ in the ongoing International Documentary and Short Film Festival at Thiruvananthapuram on the grounds that “apprehension that the documentary might affect law and order was not a valid reason to withhold sanction.” 


2-Poster-Reason-bike-orange-crop
Image Courtesy:patwardhan.com

The two writ petitioners, Kerala State Chalachitra Academy, the organizer of the festival and the filmmaker Patwardhan, approached the HC after the Ministry of Information and Broadcasting (I&B) rejected its application seeking permission for the screening of the documentary on the grounds that “the theme of the documentary was sensitive in nature and may have law and order ramifications.”

The four-hour documentary is based on the rise of religious fundamentalism in India in the backdrop of murder of rationalists such as Narendra Dabholkar, Govind Pansare, M.M.Kalburgi, Gauri Lankesh among others. The film begins by looking into the murders these rationalists and the role of the Sanatan Sanstha in spreading right-wing extremist violence. It then goes on to Dalit protests and the rise of Dalit leaders in recent years, and ends in Dadri, Mohammad Akhlaq’s village. The film has won a number of awards across the world, including the award for the Best Feature-Length Documentary at the 31st International Documentary Film Festival, Amsterdam.

According to section 9 of the Cinematograph Act, 1952, the films which are not certified by the Central Board of Film Certification requires special exemption from the Central government for public exhibition. Thus, the organizing academy had on May 27 submitted an application to the I&B Ministry seeking exemption for 161 documentaries, that were to be screened in the festival. Notably, on June 17 the Ministry sent back a list of documentaries which received exemption but Patwardhan’s film was absent from that list. After repeated attempts of finding out the reason for rejection, the Ministry finally responded yesterday stating that the film’s subject is sensitive which may cause law and order problems.

Consequently, the petitioners filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution in the HC today stating that the “mere apprehension of law and order breakdown is not a valid ground to suppress free speech.” The matter was heard by a single judge bench comprising of Justice Shaji P. Chaly.

The petitioners, represented by Advocate Sudhi Vasudevan and Jose Jones Joseph, cited the 2017 judgement of the Kerala HC which had quashed the Centre’s denial of sanction to screen the documentaries ‘March, March, March’ and ‘The Unbearable Lightness of Being’ in the same festival on the grounds that “freedom of speech and expression guaranteed by the Constitution includes the right to express one’s political views as well. Film is a legitimate and effective medium..” The two films were based on protests in JNU and suicide of Rohit Vemula respectively. 

Granting the screening permission, Justice Chaly stated that the “apprehension that the documentary might affect law and order was not a valid reason to withhold sanction. Even as per the guidelines framed by the I&B Ministry in this regard, the screening of the documentary is permissible.” However, the Judge clearly stated that the documentary should not be screened elsewhere except in the festival. 

Festival director Kamal told the New Indian Express that since the film is already available on YouTube and has been viewed many times, it does not make sense for the Centre to deny permission straight off the bat.

Anand Patwardhan is known for his socio-political, human rights-oriented films and has been a winner of several national and international awards. His films have sparked multiple controversies in the past as well, due to their strong and sometimes unpalatable messages (for the government). His films like ‘Ram ke Naam’ (on Babri Masjid demolition), ‘Father, Sun and Holy War’ (on post Babri riots), ‘A Narmada Diary’ etc led to protests from radical elements. 

The documentary and short film festival is being held from June 21 to June 26.

Related Articles:
  1. The New ‘Emergency’!
  2. A Biased Media can Weaken Democracy: Justice K.M. Joseph
  3. Today the basic question is not just of freedom of speech, but also freedom after speech

Related Articles

Monday

09

Dec

In front of Govandi station, Mumbai

Tuesday

10

Dec

Samaj Seva Kendra Hall, Dadar West, Mumbai

Saturday

07

Dec

Parel, Mumbai

Theme

Ambedkar

On India's 70th Constitution Day, the Subversive Sangh

Repeated attempts by the RSS-driven Sangh Parivar to appropriate Dr BR Ambedkar throw up contradictions and evasions
JNU

‘Stand by JNU!’ Solidarity Statements from across the world

A campaign launched by the university’s students and teachers challenging the intolerance of dissent
Hindutva

Hindutva and Democracy

Communalism Combat 9th Anniversary Special
HCU

#Stand with HCU

Solidarity Statements and Video Testimonies

Campaigns

Monday

09

Dec

In front of Govandi station, Mumbai

Tuesday

10

Dec

Samaj Seva Kendra Hall, Dadar West, Mumbai

Saturday

07

Dec

Parel, Mumbai

Videos

Freedom

Anti CAB Protests Rock the North East

Massive protests against the Citizenship Amendment Bill took place all over Assam on 9th December. Jorhar, Guwahati, Bongaigaon, Gohpur and Dhubri saw hundreds of people on the streets and the protests are said to continue.

Freedom

Anti CAB Protests Rock the North East

Massive protests against the Citizenship Amendment Bill took place all over Assam on 9th December. Jorhar, Guwahati, Bongaigaon, Gohpur and Dhubri saw hundreds of people on the streets and the protests are said to continue.

Analysis

Ambedkar

On India's 70th Constitution Day, the Subversive Sangh

Repeated attempts by the RSS-driven Sangh Parivar to appropriate Dr BR Ambedkar throw up contradictions and evasions
JNU

‘Stand by JNU!’ Solidarity Statements from across the world

A campaign launched by the university’s students and teachers challenging the intolerance of dissent
Hindutva

Hindutva and Democracy

Communalism Combat 9th Anniversary Special
HCU

#Stand with HCU

Solidarity Statements and Video Testimonies

Archives